State Rep. Joe Gibbons, Critic of Current Florida Solar Policy, Has a Conflict of Interest on the Issue, Solar Advocates Say

Corrugate via Wikimedia Commons
As we've told you earlier, there's a big, OK Corral-style showdown going on in Florida over the future of solar energy. On one side of the debate, you have a small yet scrappy band of private businesses who rig homes with solar; on the other, Florida's powerful utilities, who over the course of the summer have blocked the rooftop industry from sitting in on upcoming hearings of Florida's Public Service Commission that will likely shape new policy.

Last month, local State Rep. Joe Gibbons also stepped into the ring, criticizing the current solar policy in a Sun Sentinel op-ed. But the solar industry is now crying foul, claiming Gibbons has a conflict of interest on the issue.

Gibbons currently represents the state's 100th district. The Hallandale Beach Democrat has been term-limited out from another stay in Tallahassee, and he's currently campaigning for a Broward commission seat.

But on July 18, he penned a piece for the daily paper titled "Solar technology still needs subsidies." The piece slams the current state of solar, particularly the practice of "net metering," a state subsidy that allows homes with solar to sell back their excess power to the utilities at full retail price. It's good for the solar homeowner, but Gibbons argues the difference falls on lower- and middle-class homeowners.

But what both Gibbons and Sun Sentinel failed to mention was that the state representative is tied to the same public utilities that often shoot similar criticism at the private solar industry. Although he's not a lawyer, Gibbons makes around $60,000 a year as a "public policy advisor" for Akerman LLP, the Miami-based power-broker law firm. Previous Akerman clients include Florida utilities, including the local powerhouse Florida Power & Light.

"It seems to me you have a conflict here," says Yann Brandt, a vocal solar advocate and cofounder of South Florida's Demeter Power Group. "When you have someone who comes out against solar policies in a pretty open way, you start wondering where the motivation lies."

Gibbons, however, tells New Times his work at the firm has nothing to do with utilities or solar. He tosses away the allegation. "I wouldn't know anything about them at Akerman," he says. "I'm a public policy advisor; I deal with local government stuff. It has nothing to do with my position."

The state rep says his interest in solar has to do with his position as chair of the National Black Caucus of State Legislators' Energy, Transportation and Environment Committee. The group has passed a resolution on net metering, specifically on how it impacts poor communities.

"I'm for solar; I just want it to be fair," he tells New Times. "Why not put something together where they sell it back at a discounted rate?" Gibbons also says he'd like to see more efforts to extend solar to poorer communities. "They can't afford it. The capital costs are too high. We're in Florida, we're the Sunshine State, why not take advantage of it? But let everyone. That's the issue everyone wants to get away from."

The talk of a conflict of interest, he emphasized, was just a dodge. "I call it the politics of distraction."

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
SethPlatt topcommenter

This policy position is also shared by Americans for Prosperity the right wing political advocacy group created by Koch brothers who seek to maintain the existing dirty energy economy.


Florida is a cesspool of corruption, it must be your proximity to New York.

SethPlatt topcommenter

Some Member Corporations of the National Black Caucus of State Legislators

Alabama Power Company

BP America

Duke Energy

Edison Electric Institute

Hightowers Petroleum Company

Nuclear Energy Institute

The National Black Caucus of State Legislators' Energy, Transportation and Environment Committee:

Co Chairs of the 

Co-Chair: Ron Buford
Alabama Power

Co-Chair: Tania Archer
Duke Energy

Perhaps Rep Gibbons is being led asunder by those on this Committee if this is where this advocacy is emanating. It has been well documented that Duke Energy is seeking to claw back renewable energy incentives throughout the Southeast. I suggest he do his own independent research which points to the fact that rooftop solar provides economic benefits for ALL ratepayers.


Thank you for bringing this to light. It's well known that the legislature (who appoints the PSC members) is full of members that are getting their pockets lined, either directly or indirectly, by the investor owned utility companies. It's very hard to compete in the money game of politics, but we are scrappy.

I do take issue with the wording of the phrase, "private businesses who rig homes with solar." The vision it brings up is old-school guerrilla solar with wires hanging everywhere and nothing done to code. The solar industry is a well established group of professionals with high standards and strict codes to follow. 

In any case, it's important that constituents really know who their elected officials are really representing. The NBC and Gibbons are wrong and shortsighted on the subject. In addition, most distributed energy systems on homes and businesses do not have a net cumulative surplus of energy to sell at the end of the year anyway. Being against distributed solar energy, which reduces net energy consumption, is like being against energy star appliances, variable speed pool pumps, and LED light bulbs. Utilities talk out of both sides of their mouth, promoting energy efficiency, but trying to stifle solar energy. BOTH DO THE SAME THING - REDUCE YOUR ELECTRIC CONSUMPTION! By Gibbons logic, people who install energy saving features in their home are being unfair to all of those that don't because they are not covering their fair share of the distribution costs.

If they really cared about "fairness," they would be promoting a new rate structure that separates the distribution and production costs of electricity. But you won't hear that argument, because that's not really their goal.

Now Trending

Miami Concert Tickets

From the Vault