DEP Advisory Committee Says No to Oil Drilling in Big Cypress Swamp

Categories: Broward News

fire_ant_logo.jpg

Environmentalists took heart yesterday when a Texas oil company's request for official permission to drill deep into the Big Cypress watershed got a thumbs-down from an arm of the Department of Environmental Protection.

See also:
- Oil Companies Are Planning to Drill in Florida Panther Habitat

How great was the enviros' victory remains to be seen, however. Yesterday's panel, the Big Cypress Swamp Advisory Committee, has no veto power, and the well has already won preliminary approval from the DEP. The enviros' hopes now rest with state administrative law Judge D.R. Alexander, who must rule on legal challenges to the permit and who has indicated an interest in the advisory committee's opinion.

oilrig.jpg

The well is a project of the Dan A. Hughes Co. of Houston and would occupy but a small part of the 115,000 acres of mineral rights the company has leased from Collier Resources. Collier is the deepest pockets the enviros are up against ultimately, the owners of more than 800,000 acres of mineral rights in Southwest Florida.

Up in arms over the Hughes proposal is Preserve Our Paradise, a group of Collier County citizens' whose homes are not far from the well site and who are lead petitioner in the administrative challenge to it. Their concerns center on air and groundwater pollution, traffic congestion, and hazardous waste. They and their supporters attended yesterday's hearing en masse, according to media reports, peppering the panel with statements and questions and cheering the final 3-1 vote.

panther-wary.jpg

Also party to the administrative challenge is Matthew Schwartz, of the South Florida Wildlands Association. His special concern is the project's impact on the Florida panther, whose habitat it adjoins. "There may be 100 to 160 Florida panthers remaining," Schwartz told New Times. "And the 160 is a high-end estimate. They're living in a very small area for a big cat with a big range, so even without the intrusion of the oil industry, their fate looks grim."

DEPhearing.jpg

One of those in attendance yesterday, Dr. Karen Dwyer, a leader in the citizen activist group Stone Crab Alliance, described the advisory committee's vote as "something to smile about."

"The exact wording of the denial is something to look for when it comes out," Dwyer wrote on the group's Facebook page. "It's historic in holding Collier Resources accountable and in citing a statute that includes cumulative impacts to water, wildlife and more... A tiny victory, but a victory nonetheless that will spend a powerful message!"

Fire Ant -- an invasive species, tinged bright red, with an annoying, sometimes-fatal sting -- covers public affairs and culture in Palm Beach County and elsewhere. Got feedback or a tip? Contact Fire.Ant@BrowardPalmBeach.com.




My Voice Nation Help
6 comments
jane.carroll
jane.carroll

You are mischaracterizing the legal case.  Preserve Our Paradise, Inc. (PoP) was the first group to bring a legal challenge against the renewed oil drilling in South Florida.  Several other pro se petitions were then brought, including Matt Schwartz'.  Matt's petition was admitted, and the judge joined it to the PoP case.  While I hope Matt's case succeeds, only PoP has engaged scientific experts and legal counsel.  PoP is an all-volunteer group that is funding their experts and legal counsel solely through donations from the general public. I hope you will consider giving them your support.

labelletrawler
labelletrawler

What happened to Drill baby, Drill? Oh, not in my back yard? Better vote for Charlie Crist. Scott will let them do it.

fire.ant
fire.ant topcommenter

@jane.carroll  I misread the docket. Happy to correct.

jane.carroll
jane.carroll

@fire.ant The cases were joined.  The original Preserve Our Paradise petition is found at DOAH Case No: 13-004254.

Now Trending

Miami Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

General

Loading...