Sheriff Scott Israel Is Beefin' With the Sun Sentinel

Categories: Broward News

Obviously, the whole, like, point of newspapers is to keep the powers-that-be in check, so when the media criticize police forces or government agencies, there's not always warm fuzzies going on between them.

But yesterday, Broward Sheriff Scott Israel came out swinging after the Sun Sentinel published an October 27 editorial criticizing his leadership. He announced through BSO's official Facebook page that "nearly every key fact cited in the editorial was either wrong or purely fictional."

The Sentinel began its piece thusly:

In his relentless pursuit for more and more money, Broward Sheriff Scott Israel has lost sight of his customers and risks splintering the face of law enforcement in our community. Shortly after taking office 10 months ago, the county's top cop asked the Broward County Commission for a 14 percent budget increase -- or another $93.7 million for his $667 million budget. After receiving a still-generous 4.5 percent increase, he started looking elsewhere for more money, focused on awarding bigger staff pay raises, pensions and perks.

It then went on to give examples in various municipalities throughout the county.

This comes just two months after another Sun Sentinel piece, by columnist Michael Mayo, that began:

"Broward Sheriff Scott Israel is a political rookie, and it's showing.

As much as he tries to blame enemies and predecessor Al Lamberti for his problems, it's time for Israel and his team to face up to the off-kilter signals emanating from the Sheriff's Office.

Some leaders have the wow factor. So far, Israel keeps making me go, "Huh?"

In his first eight months, Israel had a rapper with a pending cocaine-trafficking charge perform at his swearing in, welcomed a convicted felon (ex-sheriff Ken Jenne) with open arms to BSO headquarters, and held a self-serving July news conference proclaiming a dead guy as the likely killer of BSO Sgt. Chris Reyka of Wellington in 2007.

But Israel fired back to last week's article. Here are some of his points. Read his entire letter here:

•BSO sought money for "bigger staff pay raises." Fact: It was Sheriff Lamberti who saddled the agency with the 2 percent cost-of-living increases and 5 percent seniority increases for deputies for this year and next. I am legally required to honor those signed collective bargaining agreements, and have done so. The editorial also erred in referring to this as a "5 percent cost-of-living raise and a 2 percent merit raise."

•BSO sought money for "bigger... pensions." Fact: No pension benefit increases were requested. Costs rose from a 2013 change in state law that significantly increased the employer contributions for all Florida Retirement System participants.

• "Consolidation is supposed to save taxpayers money." Fact: This statement was entirely pulled out of thin air. There has never been any consolidation plan for BSO to become the regional policing agency in all Broward cities, supplanting local police departments. Many Broward cities have their own independent police departments and have zero desire to give them up. As there was never any countywide police consolidation envisioned -- and I'm not in the business of "empire building" -- there was certainly no cost-saving promises tied to this fictional plan.

Then there were the contradictory demands of the editorial.

The editorial demanded cost savings -- yet complained that BSO was reckless to close satellite booking facilities to save money. The Sun Sentinel failed to mention that all of Florida's largest counties operate with just one central-booking intake facility. The closures bring Broward into alignment with how efficient jail systems operate today. Additionally, it produced $2.8 million in annual taxpayer savings.

I truly support fiscal responsibility, but not at the expense of providing public safety services on the cheap. I support saving tax dollars, but I support saving lives more.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

This is a total hit job by the New Times.  The New Times editors were buddies with the past Broward Sheriff Al Lamerbti (who was ponzi schemer Scott Rothstein's best buddy).  They supported the past sheriff, who lost, and now these media executives are trying to distort the record of the new Broward Sheriff Scott Israel.  I actually appreciate the new initiatives that Sheriff Israel has instituted for the homeless and for animals.  He's the best sheriff I can remember Broward having.  


I voted for Scott Israel because I thought he was the best choice for Broward Sheriff.I was right. I commend him on his involvement with the youth.His Civil Citation Program is one of the best programs I have seen to reduce youth incarceration. Sheriff Israel’s leadership is proving to be beneficial for Broward County.What was the Sun-Sentinel trying to do in their editorial about the Sheriff?They’re bitching about nothing.


I appreciate this article including Sheriff Israel’s comments which countered previous false claims made by The Sun-Sentinel.That’s an encouraging note for this reader who is tired of their ersatz investigative reporting on Sheriff Israel.I’m also encouraged because the New Times readers have the chance to see  Sheriff Israel’s statements which reveal the true stories behind the so-called “facts” that were reported in the Sun-Sentinel.No one, public officials included, should be libeled simply because of possible personal disgruntlement on the part of a newspaper's staff.


Israel responded with the truth and the Sentinel should print a retraction but they probably won't. They're perfectly happy publishing on hit piece after the other on Sheriff Israel. It's like they have nothing better to do. Every Sheriff's department in the State of Florida has had budget difficulties and chiding Sheriff Israel for just doing his job is bad for the community. Many people working at the Public Safety Building worked for Ken Jenne. His administration built the place. Felon aside, you think he might know something about the workings of BSO that he could fill in for Israel? Let's not forget, sour grapes Lamberti locked Israel out of the Public Safety Building until the very last minute and afforded him no transition whatsoever as Lamberti and cronies all escaped with golden parachutes. I'm glad Scott Israel took the time to set the record straight.

funchey1 moderator editor

@loriswitsker Hit job? It merely quotes from both sides.  Please do tell me which New Times editors were buddies with Lamberti and your basis for saying so. So curious! 

Now Trending

Miami Concert Tickets

From the Vault