Florida House Finally Considering Bill to Sort-of Compensate Eric Brody

Categories: Crime, Politics
File photo
Brody's car after A BSO deputy swerved into it in March 1998.
​Fourteen years after a speeding Broward Sheriff's Office deputy left 18-year-old Eric Brody with permanent, debilitating brain damage, it looks like the Florida Legislature is getting close to paying Brody's family the money it's owed -- OK, actually about a third of the money it's owed.

A court found the Broward Sheriff's Office culpable for more than $30 million in damages in 2005 after Deputy Christopher Thieman T-boned Brody on Oakland Park Boulevard; Thieman was speeding in his cruiser because he was running late for work. Thieman was fine; Brody was in a coma for six months. Because of a Florida law protecting public institutions from being sued for more than $200,000, the judgment has to be passed through the statehouse.

The Senate passed its version of the bill early last month, and the House's ...

... version of the bill is on the agenda of the Civil Justice Subcommittee for this morning after sitting dormant for weeks.

Though the Senate made a big deal out of passing the bill on the first day of this year's session, the legislation will award the Brodys only a fraction of their court ruling.

A report prepared for the Senate last year by special master Bram D.E. Canter recommended cutting the judgment at least in half to "avoid a precedent for the escalation of claims." The first two versions of the Senate's bill would have paid Brody about $15.8 million; the one the Senate approved awards Brody's family less than $10.8 million, which sounds like a lot until you realize it has to pay for what is essentially around-the-clock care for the rest of the 31-year-old Brody's life, plus the mounds of medical bills his family encountered following the accident.

Though the House bill as it currently reads would approve the full $30 million claim, it doesn't look like they'll be getting it. The analysis by special master Tom Thomas attached to the bill criticizes the original jury's lack of transparency in figuring out how much Brody was owed for pain and suffering, then promptly recommends the House throw almost all of it out... without any transparency.

"I find the determination of economic damages and costs in the amount of $11,647,290.30 to be reasonable and supported by competent and substantial evidence," the report says. At least he threw in the three extra dimes. The point appears to be moot anyway: The report also says the family has agreed to a $10.8 million settlement.

It had been offered as much as $12 million in the past and declined.

"I hate to be a pain in the butt," Brody's father said at the time, "but they literally destroyed my kid's life. He will never marry. He will never have a family. He's shot. He's done."

And now he's getting a third of what a court said he was owed, because some legislators and lawyers thought the number sounded too high.

And, even with the drastically reduced Senate award, two state senators voted against it. It's probably not a surprise that Gainesville Republican Sen. Stephen Oelrich voted against a bill that finds a sheriff's office liable for reckless misconduct and a disgustingly mishandled investigation: He retired in 2006 after 14 years as Alachua County sheriff.

Panhandle Republican Sen. Don Gaetz actually voted against the bill twice: Once in the Rules Committee and again when it came to the floor. If Gaetz's name sounds familiar, it's probably because he had to apologize Monday after making an analogy last week that involved hanging people.

We'll get more information about the fate of the Brodys' money after we see how the subcommittee deals with it today. This wouldn't be the first time the House failed to pass a companion bill for Brody after the Senate passed one -- it happened last year.

If you want more information about Brody's accident and his parents' subsequent struggles in caring for him, we had a feature about it two and a half years ago that highlights -- you guessed it -- how the family was struggling to collect its money.

New Times on Facebook | Twitter 
The Pulp on Facebook | Twitter 
Rich Abdill on Facebook | Twitter | Email

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

No fan of Sen. Don Gaetz, but his hanging analogy has absolutely nothing to do with racism, as was the contention of 3 fellow lawmakers ( all black). This kind of shit gets old real quick. Judge for yourself." Some people would complain if you hung them with a new rope".


Were it one of them or their families, a much different outcome would have been reached far earlier.

There is no bottom to the depths these politicians will sink in order to protect their agenda. No act so heinous that delivering justice will overcome their prejudice against the courts. No tragedy so heart wrenching that they forgo ideology and support the truth.

No words to describe how contemptible and disgusting I find their actions.

Pete Pepper
Pete Pepper

This is why the republicans want tort reform so badly.  They want to make sure they do not have to pay anyone anything, no matter how in the wrong they are. Truly disgusting.


 Don't forget his greasy lawyers, they stand to get $10 million and not a pain or suffer for any of them.

Rich Abdill
Rich Abdill

I'm a bit late to the conversation, but attorneys' fees are capped at 25 percent, if that makes you feel any better.

Mike M
Mike M

But what if they had no lawyers, then what would they get? ZERO you plonker.  The family agreed to a contingency deal, the lawyers worked on contingency, if the family recovers, the lawyers get paid, if not bumkiss, the lawyers get nothing.  It is capitalism in its purest form.  Before you shoot you mouth off with a tired, stupid comment, give it a bit of thought next time.

Rich Abdill
Rich Abdill

Correction, if anybody is still in this comments section: Fees are capped at 15 percent of the first million dollars, 10 percent of the second million, five percent of the next three million, and the rest of the money can't get touched.


A slam dunk case if I ever heard one.  The shysters took no risk, at least not $10 million worth.  This kind of shystering is why there should be a bounty on lawyers and law schools a free fire zone.

Now Trending

Miami Concert Tickets

From the Vault