Scott Rothstein's Impending Deposition Will Not Be Videotaped Due to "Security Risk"

Categories: Broward News
srothstein-Ponzi.jpg
Scott Rothstein, who can't be seen on film because of reasons that are "unusual in nature."
A deposition for Ponzi-schemer extraordinaire Scott Rothstein scheduled to be held in December will not be videotaped, a federal judge ruled earlier in the week.

Rothstein is slated to be deposed on December 12 by creditors for several civil actions in state and federal courts related to his now-defunct Rothstein Rosenfeldt Adler law firm, but U.S. District Judge James Cohn sided with the government in a ruling to eliminate the possibility of filming it.

The filing from the feds seeking to block the taping is sealed, and Cohn's ruling doesn't give the exact reasoning behind the efforts, saying his decision "effectively summarizes the Government's sealed filing, without revealing anything not already in the public record."

Cohn does make a few statements that could spark some speculation, so we'll point those out for you.

The judge says the feds cited this law meant to protect government witnesses, and he ruled in the government's favor despite the feds not citing any case law in their filing.

Cohn states the government "has shown good cause and specifically identified a serious harm," enough for him to rule in its favor, although a filing from a lawyer representing one of the creditors alleged the government did not show a "specific identification of serious harm."

As you may recall, this deposition was delayed by six months while federal prosecutors are preparing another round of indictments related to Rothstein, but that was for a different reason.

Prosecutors previously stated that they didn't want to tip off those about to be indicted, but their successful attempt to block the filming of the deposition appears to be for Rothstein's protection.

Here's about as specific as Cohn gets in his four-page ruling:

Upon a review of all the filings of this matter, the Court concludes that the Government has shown good cause and specifically identified a serious harm to justify elimination of videotaping of Rothstein's deposition. Videotaping or photographing of a protected person would create a security risk and jeopardize the safety of the protected person, as well as the potential undermining of the protection program with regard to future participants. The Government's specific information in this case is filed under seal for security reasons that are unusual in nature yet significant enough to warrant this relief. Under the appropriate balancing test, the need for the private parties to videotape Rothstein is outweighed by the security concerns raised by the Government.

In an attempt to appease the rest of us, Cohn writes, "The Court recognizes that this ruling will leave many unsatisfied, as it does not reveal the Government's specific reasons. There are rare occasions in our otherwise open society that certain information should not be publicly available."

Cohn also noted there will be no further hearings related to the videotaping of Rothstein's deposition.


Follow The Pulp on Facebook and on Twitter: @ThePulpBPB. Follow Matthew Hendley on Facebook and on Twitter: @MatthewHendley.

Advertisement

My Voice Nation Help
11 comments
Soccer shop
Soccer shop

The premiership : 0-1  first defeat at Liverpool   2011-2012 premiership season 4 round to continue and  Liverpool visit cloth tower in Virginia  challenge stadium Stoke City Football Club team. Finally Stoke City Football  Club 1-0 defeat Liverpool, get the new  premiership season first defeat, waters wear cheap soccer cleats credit creation into scored the only goal  in the game. At the same time they also continued in the premier league with  opponents away without a victory.The game Liverpool captain Steven gerrard like  to buy soccer cleats is still lack and left-back Fabio Aurelio wear nike soccer cleats, jamie carragher wear adidas soccer cleats Seattle wear the captain's armband on  appear in the right-back position, Martin Skrtel wear puma soccer cleats with  agger's as central defender combination, left-back is Jose Enrique Sanchez Diaz wear mizuno soccer cleats, goalkeeper pepe reina wear cheap soccer jerseys , Midfield:  downing wear cesc fabregas cleats, Charlie Adam wear andres iniesta  cleats, Gerald  Henderson wear wayne rooney cleats and Lucas Pezzini Leiva wear wesley sneijder  cleats,Striker  line is Dirk Kuyt wear fernando torres  cleats to  partner with Luis Alberto Suárez wear gerard pique cleats, Andy  Carroll wear sergio aguero cleats is still on the bench.21 minutes, Stoke City Football Club high  ball into the box, waters wear ronaldinho cleats rob hanging living body position, jamie  carragher wear cristiano ronaldo  cleats passive, referee decisions under forced to foul penalty, a penalty to directly  into waters wear didier drogba cleats middle, Pepe Reina wear zlatan ibrahimovic  cleats flapping in the wrong direction, Stoke City Football Club 1-0 Liverpool.Liverpool 0-1 eventually fail at the stadium. Virginia cloth towerLiverpool starting list (4-4-2)  :The goalkeeper pepe reina: 25- Pepe Reina  wear pato cleats Guard: 37- Martin Skrtel wear kaka soccer cleats (82 minutes, 2- Glen Johnson wear van persie cleats), 23 jamie carragher wear nani cleats, 5- Daniel Agger wear lionel messi soccer  cleats, 3- Jose Enrique Sanchez Diaz wear david villa cleats Midfielder: 14- Gerald Henderson wear nike ctr360 maestri ii  elite (67  minutes, 39- Craig Bellamy wear nike total 90 laser iii), 21- Lucas Pezzini Leiva wear nike total 90 laser elite, 26- Charlie Adam wear nike tiempo legend iv, 19, Charlie Adam downing wear nike mercurial vapor  superfly Striker: 7- Luis Suarez wear nike mercurial vapor  superfly ii, 18-  Dirk Kuyt wear nike mercurial vapor  superfly ii safari (67  minutes, 9 carol wear nike mercurial vapor  superfly iii)Substitute not debut: 32- Donieber  Alexander Marangon wear nike mercurial vapor  superfly safari iii, 11-  Maxi Rodriguez wear adidas world cup sg, 16- Sebastian  Coates, 20- Jay SpearingStoke city starting list (4-4-2)  :The goalkeeper's: 1- Asmir Begovic wear adidas f50 adizero prime  trx Guard: 4- Robert Huth (65 minutes, 28- Andy  Wilkinson wear adidas f50 adizero womens), 17- Ryan Shawcross, 20- Matthew James  Upson wear adidas f50 adizero trx, 12- mark WilsonMidfielder: 16- jermaine pennant wear adidas adipower predator  trx, 24-  Rory Delap, (71minutes, 40 Wilson Roberto Palacios Suazo wear adidas predator x trx), 18- Dean Whitehead, (68 minutes, 9 Jones  wear adidas adipure iv trx), 26- Matthew EtheringtonStriker: 25, Peter crouch, 19, watersSubstitute not debut: 29 sorensen, 6 Theresa  whelan, 33 Jerome

Soccer shop
Soccer shop

The FA Premier League: Arsenal 1-0 won Swansea Cityea   City     2011-12 premier  league season 4 all round launched, in the first 3 round 1 and losing two only  into the two goals but lost 10 of the ball, Arsenal at home have promoted the Swansea  City' west challenge. After 90 minutes guild wars, the Arsenal of home games a  1-0 victory over west get Swansea City' first win the premiership this season,  andrei arshavin.wear soft ground soccer cleats scored  the only goal in all.  The  30 minutes, andrei arshavin.wear indoor soccer shoes is  Simon will Swansea Cityea City's goalkeeper Michel  Vorm wear artificial ground  soccer cleats on  the edge of the area, the Russian czar rush for a penalty, the referee awarded  only Arsenal a corner. 36 minutes, Swansea City' west open in the corner, and Scott Sinclair wear hard ground soccer cleats forced shot is blocked, then per mertesacker wear firm ground soccer cleats shoveled the ball. 41th minutes in the game, Arsenal finally lead, Swansea  City' goalkeeper Michel Vorm wear turf soccer cleats will  hand the ball to hit the ball inside his own mistakes, and the defender hit the  Andrei Arshavin wear mizuno wave ignitus feet, small Angle Russian  shot successful, 1-0!  Finally,  Arsenal 1-0 win at home to swans' west, a difficult first win the premiership  has this season.   Both  sides played list:  Arsenal  (4-5-1)  Goalkeeper:  13- Wojciech Szczesny wear puma powercat 1.10,  Guard:  3- Bakari Sagna, 6- Laurent Koscielny wear adidas f50 adizero prime , 4- per  mertesacker, 28- Kieran Gibbs wear adidas f50 adizero trx   Midfielder:  14- Theo Walcott, 8- Mikel Arteta wear mizuno soccer cleats, 26-  Emmanuel Frimpong wear adidas adipower predator (74  '39- Coquelin), 16- Aaron  James Ramsey wear adidas predator x trx, 23-  Andrei Arshavin wear adidas soccer cleats (62'  30- Yossi  Benayoun)  Striker:  10- Robin van Persie wear adidas adipure iv trx (81  '29- Marouane Chamakh)  The Swansea City' (4-5-1)  Goalkeeper:  1- Michel Vorm wear nike mercurial vapor superfly ii   Guard:  22- Angel Rangel, 3-Neil Taylor wear nike mercurial vapor superfly iii,  4-exam Kerr wear nike soccer cleats , 2-Williams wear nike tiempo legend ii   Midfielder:  24-Joe Allen, 7-britten wear nike total 90 laser  iii , 26,  was the grace wear soccer cleats, 12- Nathan Dyer wear nike ctr360 maestri ii elite, 11-  Scott Sinclair wear puma soccer cleats   Striker:  Danny Graham like to soccer cleats buy

Soccer shop
Soccer shop

Real Sociedad de Fútbol VS Barcelona football club football club forward   11 to 12 season  three rounds, west huge will be in Barcelona  football club away against Real Sociedad de Fútbol, Barcelona football club last season on the  road wheels 34 have 1-2 defeat by opponents. adidas f50 adizero womens first  round read spell as Barcelona  football clubDue  to the first round of the program because of the strike, and the third wheel is  actually deferred second round. Barcelona football club have not good at  playing league start, the past nine years,-10 season completed only for the  first three rounds streak, the rest of the season is be within three rounds, adidas f50 adizero trx, 9 season 5 wins the  first round 3 flat 1 negative, of which half lost time occurs in the first  round for the breakout, adidas adipower predator trx, the most famous is at  home last season by the hittite, library. First round easily lose points  because it is located in the first round of the season after FIFA matchday, adidas predator x trx, and first in the  season's champions league matchday, by the main players before before ousting  the suffering of consumption, the uefa champions league after start wars  distraction, large-scale rotation is difficult to avoid, adidas adipure iv trx, the team fighting it  normal. Low So this Real Sociedad de Fútbol can beat Barcelona football club, whether for parents  to repeat mistakes, is the second biggest attraction. adidas f50 adizero prime trx read  all be suspended tookExcept  in the FIFA matchday no depleted, Barcelona football club before this good  news, even receive a ban's Daniel Alves da Silva wear cheap soccer cleats and David  Villa Sánchez like to buy soccer cleats ", a large number of the wounded back the release "squad, including  long-term injury stop Puyol wear nike soccer cleats,  summer carles puyol thigh strain ligaments in the United States Carles Ibrahim  Afellay wear adidas soccer cleats, spain  super cup for minor injuries of Adriano Leite  Ribeiro wear puma soccer cleats and Maxwell  Sherer Cabeliro Andrade wear mizuno soccer cleats, in addition Eric Abidal wear cheap soccer jerseys and Seydou Keita wear fernando torres cleats Ramadan  has over, since the champions league final Barcelona football club first team  since the height of the personnel.big  rotation starting next guessIt is  imperative to starting rotation, it is not difficult to guess. The world sports  daily gives the FIFA break before Barcelona football club starting three can be  found rule, the central axis much dwell, Lionel messi wear lionel messi soccer cleats in  the national team often after returning from the new signing off, the more  start. So the Andrés Iniesta wear wayne rooney cleats and Thiago  Alcantara wear wesley sneijder cleats composition midfielder, cesc fabregas wear cesc fabregas cleats and David  Villa Sánchez wear gerard pique cleats at  least one person was expected to start.Both  sides suspended players:Barcelona football club: Gerard Pique wear sergio aguero cleats (hurt)Real  Sociedad de Fútbol: Carlos Martinez wear ronaldinho cleats (ban)  red cardThe  starting:Barcelona football club (4-3-3)  :Goalkeeper  valdes: 1- Victor Valdes Arribas wear cristiano ronaldo cleats Guard:  2- Daniel Alves da Silva wear didier drogba cleats, 14-  Javier Alejandro Mascherano wear zlatan ibrahimovic cleats, 26-  Andreu Fontàs Prat wear pato cleats, 19- Maxwell Sherer Cabeliro Andrade wear kaka soccer cleats Midfielder:  15- Seydou Keita wear van persie cleats, 8-  Andrés Iniesta wear nani cleats, 11- Thiago Alcantara  wear andres iniesta cleats Striker:  17- Pedro Rodriguez Ledesma wear david villa cleats, 7-  David Villa Sánchez wear nike ctr360 maestri ii elite, 9- Alexis Alejandro  Sanchez wear nike total 90 laser iii Real  Sociedad de Fútbol (4-4-2) :Goalkeeper:  1- Carlos Bueno wear nike total 90 laser elite Guard:  26- Carlos Martinez wear nike tiempo legend iv, 16-Randolph wear nike mercurial vapor superfly,  3-predecessor Gonzalez wear nike mercurial vapor superfly ii,  24-Della Bella wear nike mercurial vapor superfly ii safari,Midfielder:  17-Zulu figure gaza  wear nike mercurial vapor superfly iii,  11-ALanBuLu door wear nike mercurial vapor superfly safari iii

Striker:  9, gillett jr wear adidas  world cup sg

Soccer shop
Soccer shop

Real Madrid VS Getafe  Club de Fútbol Club de Fútbol preview: two iron waist regression   The huge three rounds of a focus fights in  the bernabeu began, real Madrid and team  Getafe Club de Fútbol for the same city to a Derby.  Meeting record: real Madrid five straight only lost one at home  Both sides league history, though, real Madrid 14 games eight  wins and two draws negative 4 the upper hand. With almost five meetings, the  whites keep voles, home record is five wins and a draw 1 negative. Last  season's first leg, Alvaro Arbeloa () accumulative total was sent off for two  yellow CARDS, real Madrid a man less 3-2 narrow victory, at home to the 4-0  victory over.   Big list: had NaLuo raghuraman back  One day before the news that, Sami Khedira  wear soft ground soccer cleats because the injury to miss the opening of  the games had to pull, still do not reach the requirements of the match  fitness, but mourinho is still will fill the Germany international 20 list, it  looks like there were no serious problems. The same is Esteban Granero wear indoor soccer  shoes return and Varane wear artificial  ground soccer cleats , Nuri Sahin wear hard ground  soccer cleats and Hamit Altintop wear firm ground  soccer cleats still missing, but orchis by those who enter 18  people even before jose mourinho decided to list. Where all didn't go to pull, Lassana Diarra wear turf soccer  cleats, with the team training but still not in the squad.   Cristiano ronaldo wear mizuno wave  ignitus, Getafe Club de Fútbol's buster  Two leg last season against Getafe Club de  Fútbol, cristiano ronaldo wear puma powercat  1.10 guest war field goals scored two goals and home a  hat-trick, two games into five goals. And according to media statistics, nearly  five rounds of the cross season, scoring 14 league cristiano ronaldo wear adidas f50 adizero prime 7 ball, averaging 2.8 ball, terrorist data has transcended the-all the clubs  such as Hugo Sánchez Márquez wear adidas f50  adizero trx legendary striker, see home could take Derby  offering flag.  Jose mourinho's first rev. Rotation kaka wear adidas  adipower predator expected to start  Two international weeks to the foot, large  Numbers of real Madrid surely ye have influence, especially next week and more  difficult to play in the champions league group stages, and is expected to jose  mourinho will also small rotation, will be the new season three official games  for the first time since. The marca "revealed, didn't get the call-up kaka  wear adidas  predator x trx, Brazil's most promising won their first start to  fill seats, as for the Mesut Oezil wear adidas  adipure iv trx or Angel Di María wear nike  mercurial vapor superfly iii return to see jose mourinho ideas.   The two sides are expected to start:  Real Madrid (the 4-2-3-1)  : Iker Casillas Fernández wear nike  mercurial vapor superfly iic; Sergio Ramos García, Kepler  Laveran Lima Ferreira wear nike tiempo  legend ii, Ricardo Alberto Silveira Carvalho, Marcelo Vieira da  Silva Junior wear nike total 90  laser iii, Fabio Coentrao, Xabi Alonso, Angel Di María wear nike ctr360  maestri ii elite, Mesut Oezil, cristiano ronaldo wear puma soccer  cleats ,  Karim Benzema

Getafe Club de Fútbol (4-4-2)  : Miquel Moya wear mizuno soccer  cleats; Miguel Torres, Cata Diaz wear adidas soccer cleats, bartholomew,  marcie laila; Pedro Rios wear nike soccer cleats , Javi Casquero, Rafa Lopez wear soccer cleats,  Sarah via; MiKu like soccer cleats buy

Ruagatr
Ruagatr

Obviously rothstein has had plastic surgery and is in the witness protection program...so they cannot reveal his current looks.

Lifelong Dem
Lifelong Dem

Cohn's ruling can be appealed, obviously.

ConnieConartista
ConnieConartista

How are you going to pick up the micro-expressions Rothstein's exhibiting if you can't videotape the deposition?  Why don't the just videotape it and seal the results (?) ... or maybe it won't matter.  Maybe the other crooks will already have been rounded up and awaiting trial by December.  Better speed up that new courthouse construction.  The legal community will be walking tall in there soon, but many of them this time in shackles.  Is the 8th floor of the courthouse still going to be referred to as "snootytown"?  Just wondering...

Diogenes6670
Diogenes6670

Plastic surgery, and he's likely to testify behind a screen or under a hood.

qwerty
qwerty

Not yet - it is not a final, appealable order disposing of all the issues in the case.  The judge has wide discretion.  My guess is there will never be a video depo of him.

Now Trending

Miami Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

Auto

Loading...