Chief Judge: Scott Rothstein's Firm Has "No Money" and Is Going Into Receivership
![]() |
| Tobin |
"[I]f you have a case with the firm please be patient I don't know if the lawyers will come or not and if they do come there is no money at this point to go forward with the case or pay firm employees," Tobin wrote.
The text of Tobin's incredible email comes after jump.
To: ALL JUDGES, ALL JAS
From: Judge Tobin/17THCircuit
Date: 11/02/2009 6:45AM
Subject: RE Rothstein Rosenflelt [sic] and Adler
I learned of some very distressing news yesterday. Rothstein Rosenfeldt and Adler will be asking us to appoint a receiver for the law firm today. Please whoever draws the case try to set the motion today because of the amount of clients and money involved. Also if you have a case with the firm please be paitent I don't know if the lawyers will come or not and if they do come there is no money at this point to go forward with the case or pay firm employees. They need to a receiver apointed a quickly as possible to marshall whatever is left of the assets.
Vic Tobin
59 comment(s) / Post a Comment
I'm a little concerned with our Chief Judge. Does he have spell check?
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 10:44AMhow is Nurik being paid to defend Scott Rothstein? Howcome Rothstein has money to pay for a defense yet the firm's client's are left without counsel. this is crap.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 10:45AMYou want to know something funny? You actually made me think about the law. I managed to go through three years of law school without doing that.
Be Well Scott!
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 10:46AMVic Tobin is another one of Mr. Rothstein's supposed "good friends," so it will be interesting to see how he handles the Receivership. I like to see a judge with a heart, but when my clients go bankrupt, they generally do not receive the same level of sympathy from the court, or a priority setting on their motions. I guess its "good to be the king" even when the king is wearing no clothes (or should I say no custom made designer suits).
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 10:47AMWhat the hey? Why is Chief Judge Tobin advocating for a private law firm? Favoritism and cronyism at its worst. He should be investigated too.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 10:56AMMaybe seems like something that would not always happen, but if a (big) firm goes down, for the benefit of the clients it does seem prudent to warn judges that there is more to the failure to appear or in motions that maybe filed on emergency basis. If reports are true the FBIs are there, it may be difficult to take the files out of the office for pending hearings. Ultimately, no one wants the clients to be (futher) victimized.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 10:57AMTow trucks are starting to tow very expensive vehicles right now. This is not pretty.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 11:00AMWow, I feel real confident my client will get a fair hearing against an RRA lawyer now. My client is thrilled too. Bias, anyone?
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 11:03AMTobin is clearly showing favoritism to his good buddy Rosenfeldt. The JQC needs to look into Tobin's connection with RRA. How does Tobin know all the details ans why is he telling judges how they should rule in advance. And, by the way, is Tobin a total clown with his grammar and spelling?
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 11:08AMPulp, why do you think Tobin's e-mail is incredibe? I looked at the RRA website, and looking at the lawyers there, it seems like Tobin has reason(s) to give them preferential treatment. Names like Dishowitz, Birken, (Judges sons or daughters I believe) It must be nice to get insider help from the Chief Judge.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 11:10AMTobin also regularly goes to lunch with many of the lawyers in RRA firm. No wonder Tobin ORDERED the judges to give RRA favorable treatment. This is incredible and all Broward judges need to be disqualified now since Tobin has created an appearance of impropriety. Tobin's actions are clearly unethical and need to be investigated asap.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 11:18AMWow! The Chief Judge bending over backwards at 6 in the morning telling other judges to be on the look out to help this ponzi scheme masquerading as a law firm.
Geeze, I wonder if cheese and crackers are being put out for the poor, downtrodden lawyers at the firm?
Maybe they can go downstairs and nosh on something at Bova downstairs while waiting for the well groomed men and women to finish up there work for the day.
It appears that there might be a lock down in the IT department and these silly bums might not be able to cover matters in a timely manner.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 11:19AMTobin's conduct is as questionable as his English
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 11:22AMcan you imagine an arrogant prick like lil petey dijols can be in a black robe, making life changing decisions that affected lives, families, children can brag about being hired by this madoff wanna be thug and have no idea of his larceny.why would anyone trust what is going on at the broward cty court house????and poor eileen o'connor, there goes your meal tix when you get voted out.if lil petey dijols can't figure out the numbers, balance sheet, income statement of a law firm to wonder how a guy buys 2 lamborghinis etc while this whole economy is on it's ass, is a joke.this joker and his comrades bragged about ex judges, prosecutors{ that have been accused of lying under oath} being partners, and now tobin is showing his colors, pls pity the poor downtrodden going to court today. on a cold ass bus, b/c they have not had a break in life.why can people who don't have to steal other then to be a pig get easier treatment than someone needs to steal, deal etc to get a meal????THINK ABOUT BROWARD CTY!!!satz, marcus, cohen, morton, and all the wanna be tough asa's like the lying tommie coleman need to go.esp , coleman, let him go to daddy in law, and wifey, but he is the epitome of what satz trains his subordinates to do.keep feathering the nests of political supporters while hammering the disenfranchised to put out bogus crime figures at election time.satz, there 2 feet of snow, go away, you are alil lying putz!!!!!!
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 11:28AMThis Judge Tobin should not have touched this with a 10 foot pole. The system has rules for the litigants to use to ask for emergency hearings. For the Chief Judge to get personally involved does not pass the smell test. PU
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 11:29AMConsider what he said: (1) Motion is being filed (smart lawyers called ahead); (2) set the matter today (nothing wrong with that) considering what is at stake; (3) receiver needs to marshall assets asap (true). How does this help SR?
If Tobin had not done that, AND this had set into drift for a few days because judges either recusing themsleves or naturally "too busy" to hear important matters, then everyone would be screaming he knew about it and didnt do anything (and alleging he didnt do anything because he was friends with so-and-so) allowing assets to dissipate. Seriously, get a grip. Everyone loves a conspiracy plot but stretching it because he says get on this asap.
The point is that the firm is collapsing, clients deserve to protect their assets given to the firm, those entitled to the assets (Creditors or otehrwise) should have confidence that a firm which has so demonstrably shown an inability to manage itself does not let the assets disappear, and all this should be done quickly.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 11:31AMPulp, Can you find out how much Judge Tobin has received from Scott and his minions in campaign contributions over the years?
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 11:32AMI wonder if this dude is still threatening people. I wonder if this dude has the temerity to threaten an employee of a large national law enforcement agency like he did to so many others.
I would pay anything to see that!
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 11:47AMwe have a former sherriff, {supposedly tough on crime} and an obnoxious arrogant judge petey dijols who would spout off at will{ who bragged about being a former state wide special prosecutor, and they all went to the knees of this crook.and we all sit back and allow this to happen??? 2 guys who told us they knew how to spot crime, adjudicate criminals, but woke up to a place of their much needed employment to find it insolvent??VOTE OUT ALL INCUMBENT JUDGES!!!AND THEN THERE IS THE BIG QUESTION, WHERE WAS MIKE SATZ??????having coucous and lamb kibi w/ rothstein?????arranged by jenne, dijols, or maybe his best ski pal scheinberg???????clean house broward cty, and now we have seiler, a willing reciepient of rothsteins stolen money, appointed to tell us about other corruption that went on under his nose.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 12:01PMI cannot wait until the FBI gets into the whole Broward County School Board and starts looking at where the money went, who voted for what and who got what jobs where.
You dirty cretins better hide and hope that you are not detected.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 12:12PMany bets on whether he returns from Morocco to face the music?
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 12:14PMThe Sun-Sentinel is reporting that a lawsuit was filed against Rothstein by his law partner Rosenfeldt.
Please post when you get a copy of it.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 12:29PMWhy do you think RRA hired Sean Birken and Ben Dishowitz? Maybe it was because they are the sons of sitting Broward Circuit Court judges. With Scott, it was always about buying influence or the appearance of influence so hiring a judge's son makes good business sense whether they can find the courthouse or not.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 12:37PMIt looks like Mr. Rosenfeldt sued his best friend Scott today....maybe the case will be assigned to Judge Tobin.
Case Summary
Broward County Case Number: CACE09059301 State Reporting Number: 062009CA059301AXXXCE
Court Type: Civil Division - Circuit Court Case Type: Other Civil
Incident Date: N/A Filing Date: 11/02/2009
Court Location: Central Courthouse Case Status: Pending
Magistrate ID / Name: N/A Judge ID / Name: 07 Rosenberg, Robert A.
Style: Stuart Rosenfeldt, et al Plaintiff vs. Scott Rothstein Defendant
Party Detail
Party Type
Party Name
Sex
Race
D.O.B.
D.O.D.
Attorneys / BarID
Denotes Lead Attorney
Plaintiff
Adler, Rothstein Rosenfeldt
Plaintiff
Rosenfeldt, Stuart A Coffey, Kendall B
Retained
BarID: 259861
Defendant
Rothstein, Scott W
Do they have to serve him with the lawsuit or is he going to stay put out of town and evade service?
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 12:49PMThe Rosenfeldt v. Rothstein lawsuit was assigned to Circuit Court Judge Robert Rosenberg, who I hear is is a good friend of Stuart (but not Scott). I guess we are going to see a recusal here since I can't think of any judge at the courthouse that would want to touch this hot potato. Maybe Governor Crist will appoint a special judge from outside of Broward to hear the case, but then again, that would give the appearance of favortism towards his good buddy Scott. What a tangled web he wove.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 1:07PMwhat a joke.remember the article on the rothstein women lawyers?? how would you like to pay 350/hour to have their judgement, experience, counsel????? is there going to be a bova in morroco, or maybe a blue martini.i'd love to see lil petey dijols w/ an apron pouring the water while ken jenne serves the goat goulash.does anyone realize the power these guys had, abused and laughed all the way to what they thought was a bank? but apperently w/ all their crime busting expertise, they did not know willie sutton already had the keys.again,where was mike satz that his best pal scheinberg was next to the vault????? just a flippen vulgar joke!!!!!!!!!
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 1:13PMTWO LAMBORGHINI'S, plus all the other expensive goodoes!? No wonder scumbag attorney's get $500 bux plus an hour. They have to pay for their toys at the expense of the public. My advice: DON'T VOTE FOR LAWYERS! Clean the Executive and Lwegislative Branch and all Local Governments of lawyers, and you'll see the tide turn. Until then...BOHICA BROWARD!
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 1:14PMThe ultimate of flaunts had to be the recently acquired Jewish Avenger Mobile, also known as a Bugatti Veyron....Step aside Batman......What a JOKE....
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 1:23PMYes, enough of the "friendly" stuff! Get rid of all this corruption. No wonder it took RRA ONE YEAR to pay me some money they had in escrow...
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 1:45PMJudge Rosenberg needs to recuse himself from this case. This stinks and the FBI needs to investigate.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 1:53PMGee what a shock!! Guy spends money like water all over town and never really works at his craft is a scammer. No suprise.
There have been thousands of large lawfirms where the managing partner did not make enough monet to buy even the house Scotty bought. So how could he and the others be making so much money. I guess they aren't. Says lawfirm has no cash.
What a sham.
Real question is if his arm candy wife is smart enough to stash all of teh jewels she bought at Levinsons....
Dear Chief Judge Tobin and JQC:
Someone directly or indirectly contacted Tobin early this morning and reached out to him.(EXPARTE) It is believed it was his very good friend Stuart Rosenfeldt. Tobin then tells all of the judges how to help out a party on a case that at the time he sent out the email was yet to be filed. Did Rosenfeldt or someone connected with the RRA firm contact Tobin? Tobin directs the judge who gets this case to prioritize it over all other cases in Broward County and to take it easy on any RRA attorneys. He the judge to set the case immediately. This whole process does not pass the smell test and Tobin is playing favorites with RRA firm over any other law firm or case that could have equal problems. Who contacted you this morning Vic? This conduct needs to be investigated. Vic, will you do this on any case or only "special" cases?
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 3:00PMNothing wrong with what Tobin did. All he did was inform judges to be patient in case RRA lawyers dont show so that their clients aren't affected. Frankly, I would think that appointing a receiver would be exactly what Rothstein doesn't want, and so Tobin's email kind of works in favor of the innocent lawyers and clients at RRA, not Rothstein.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 4:31PMJUDGE TOBIN WAS ON TARGET. HE NOTIFIED ATTORNEYS OF THE FACTS. NOTHING MORE. NOTHING LESS.
GERALD SCHWARTZ
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 4:50PMvic, pls get o'coonor, lee{ the guy wearing garter belts under his robe, if you believe hearsay}but clean up your/our mess!!!!!!!!! EVERYONE, VOTE OUT INCUNMBENTJUDGES AND FOR LIFE POLITICIANS!its just time , long time over due, to send people to vote their conscience, not their WALLET!!!!!!!!!for a short period of time, not get a pension, health care, non of us have a chance of get ting. and pls, let me not have to remind all of us who pays their tab.IF YOU WERE DINING , WOULD YOU BE A GENEROUS TIPPER?????HAVE OUR WAITERS/SERVERS GIVEN US GOOD SERVICE??I GUESS THE ANALOGY WOULD BE, WHAT IF YOUR SERVER STOLE FROM YOUR CREDIT CARD????you would have a fit.WHY ARE OUR YOUNG MEN & LADIES DYING TO TELL THE TALIBAN THEY ARE CROOKED??????. when we got them un our own cack yard.protected by tribal chifs likk satz, jenne, scheinberg,, seiler, zaden, tobin, et al.shame on anyone that lets tis cty/country operate in ways we go to war for, but tolerate it in our own back yards.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 5:09PMPlease leave Vic alone he did nothing wrong, he's only trying to claen up the s**t i left behind
Salam Aleihem
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 5:21PMif there was something wrong w/ a case at 6:45 AM , for any reason, and a defendant/ accused. possibly accuse, there is NO WAY tobin gets a quick hearing.think for a while kids, a 18 yr old black man on a VOP, for residue, whatever, would tobin ask any judge at 6:45AM for a quick hearing????????COME ON boys and girls!!!!but when a 100 million dollarscould be stolen, lost as opposed to a life at risk in a cage, this creep tobin is concerned???????its is going to stop,vic, you are no different than ross, marko, gallagher, jenne, et al. and most of all, the lil bug eared mike satz who has been complicit in teaching you all to hammer the powerless, and turn a to deaf ear to the powerful's crimes.don't you judges have that sculpture { blind justice} in your chambers??is that just decoration, or is it what you were taught, swore to under oath , and BELIEVE?????????
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 5:33PMThe Tobin supporters are totally missing the point- he is supposed to be neutral. You and Tobin are presuming that SR is guilty of fraud but that no one else in his firm was involved. Ok for the readers to presume that, but not ok for Tobin to presume that or anything else. To top it off, Tobin then uses his position as Chief Judge to help the RRA firm. That is just flat wrong. No one knows the full facts of this yet, and Tobin should not have been involved at all.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 5:40PMI don't see that Tobin was out of line one bit. He is in the business of running the courthouse. His memo did not suggest anything improper. A law firm of 75 plus lawyers vaporizing overnight can/will cause administrative issues at the courthouse and the chief judge appeared to be attempting to address them. As far as the judge who got this case- Judge Striesfeld is a BAD MF'er. I am happy that it went to him. if anyone can cut through the bs and ignore the politics, he is the one(at least until it gets dragged into banyruptcy/federal court- which is coming) he will not put up with any crap from anyone. The partners are in for a shit storm of civil claims... it is going to get real ugly fast. This is not really about Tobin and what people think about him or the courthouse- it's all about that dirtbag Rothstein and his (now)crying partner/s.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 8:25PMTobin is the scum of the earth for getting involved, particularly since it is a known fact that Tobin and Plaintiff Rosenfeldt are very close friends. Tobin is disgusting.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 8:25PMAre you for real. How do you think Tobin got the information...someone by the name of Rosenfeldt contacted him at his house. Nothing wrong with a party contacting a judge? Maybe all lawyers should contact the unethical Tobin when they have an emergency. ETHICS 101
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 8:32PMHow about if Tobin instead said "do not give this case priority because it is not an important case."....any ethical problems with that scenario? The Judicial Qualifications Commission needs to look into this unethical conduct.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 10:34PMI don't see that Tobin was out of line one bit. He is in the business of running the courthouse. His memo did not suggest anything improper. A law firm of 75 plus lawyers vaporizing overnight can/will cause administrative issues at the courthouse and the chief judge appeared to be attempting to address them. As far as the judge who got this case- Judge Striesfeld is a BAD MF'er. I am happy that it went to him. if anyone can cut through the bs and ignore the politics, he is the one(at least until it gets dragged into banyruptcy/federal court- which is coming) he will not put up with any crap from anyone. The partners are in for a shit storm of civil claims... it is going to get real ugly fast. This is not really about Tobin and what people think about him or the courthouse- it's all about that dirtbag Rothstein and his (now)crying partner/s.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 2 2009 @ 11:40PMword on the street is this is just getting rolling. Two local guys alone claim to be out 130m & Scottie has 50m stashed - bet he goes south to hang with Hugo C. where no American gets turned over....
Posted On: Tuesday, Nov. 3 2009 @ 12:00AM
Did S Rosenfeld - rRa- get a new Ferrari from Scott r (meet me in Venezula next year Kim)othstein very recently? Is that why he is crying like a bitch?
OMG, I just read Tobin email. PULP INQUIRE MORE OF TOBIN. Tobin says he "learned of something yesterday." From whom? Then he states what he learned: "Rothstein, Rosenfeldt and Adler will be asking us to appoint a receiver..." Who would know this information other than someone directly related to the firm? Then he INSTRUCTS the judge who gets the case "to set the motion today because of the amount of clients and money involved." Again, who would have this information, other than someone directly involved with this case? He then INSTRUCTS all judges that 'have a case with the firm to be patient because I don't know if the lawyers will come or not and if they do come THERE IS NO MONEY AT THIS POINT TO GO FORWARD WITH THE CASE OR PAY THE FIRM EMPLOYEES." How did Tobin know this very detailed inside information? Tobin finishes the email with additional INSTRUCTIONS as to how the judge should rule (although his use of the English language is nursery school like): "They need a receiver appointed a quickly as possible to marshall whatever is left of the assets." WOW, MORE INSIDE INFORMATION was given to Tobin. WHO WAS TOBIN TALKING TO AND WHO IS HE TO TELL JUDGES HOW TO RULE IN A CASE?
Posted On: Tuesday, Nov. 3 2009 @ 9:44AMhaving no ties to anyone, I'll chime in. Tobin could have been a bit more circumspect, but an event like this absolutely warrants the e-mail to the other judges, who need to know this info. And there's nothing wrong with someone at the firm calling Tobin to give him the news. There is no case pending before him, so it's not ex-parte. it's exactly what a chief or administrative judge is supposed to do.
Posted On: Tuesday, Nov. 3 2009 @ 11:50AMOk, its not Tobin's case, but as the Chief Judge, doesn't his order to help out the RRA lawyers carry alot of weight? And who should be entitled to whatever money RRA has left? The RRA lawyers? Their clients? Other creditors? Why should the Chief Judge take a position on this (he seems to think its the RRA lawyers?), and then ask other judges who might get those cases to give RRA the edge in court? I don't think this sounds right.
Posted On: Tuesday, Nov. 3 2009 @ 1:01PMDear Judge Tobin,
I have a multi-million dollar company that employs 300 people who all will be out of a job tomorrow because we have lost all our money overnight. Do you mind if I call you at home to discuss favorable treatment for my company since we have no money left and need a receiver appointed. Also, please make sure all of the judges are patient with my lawyer(s) and are instructed to appoint a receiver immediately. Call me asap. We know you helped RRA and are sure you will be just as sympathetic to us.
Sincerely,
Ethics 101
Posted On: Tuesday, Nov. 3 2009 @ 1:13PMGee the judge acts as if he has a stake in this! Interesting.
Posted On: Sunday, Nov. 8 2009 @ 2:46AMWow - Broward County has many "insider" problems, Word is that RRA will chapter out soon.
Posted On: Monday, Nov. 9 2009 @ 4:24PMGod please bless this Broward County. Please let it rise above the corruption that appears to prevail . . . oozing out of evey crevis. What a lovely city this has been and can be. Please Lord, save this county.
Posted On: Wednesday, Nov. 11 2009 @ 1:12AMPlease free the powers that be of greed and self-serving interest. Please cleanse our elected officials. Please allow all of the people of Broward County the sight to see that their ellected officials are just human beings who eat and sleep and dream and hope and . . . just like the rest of us. These are mere humans . . . no different than you and I. You pay their salaries. Uncloak them. Remove the mystery. Give them no more power than they deserve. Give them no more respect that the respect that they earn. These are just people with jobs. Until we get that, Broward can not thrive as it should. Their dreams of retirement and pension and power are worldly. They are worldly. God save Broward County.
Posted On: Wednesday, Nov. 11 2009 @ 1:21AMJudge Tobin, by virtue of this email, cannot now preside over the statewide grand jury. In addition, the Rothstein firm has given him campaign cash. Good grief.
Posted On: Thursday, Dec. 3 2009 @ 7:35PMAfter Tobin's email hit the fan here, he claimed that it was privileged! Is he nuts? It is a public record, fully discoverable under the Rules of Judicial Administration. This guy is a Chief Judge?
Posted On: Thursday, Dec. 3 2009 @ 7:37PM














