Should Ethics Be Put Aside When the Boss Asks for Chilean Sea Bass? Or, Worse, Foie Gras?
|Chilean sea bass: delicious and ethically questionable.|
The flavors melded together beautifully: the tangy, warm tomato and red onions over the sweet fish with the garlicky, tender zucchini, on top of the nutty brown rice. To top it off, it was paired with a supple meursault. Just enough finesse to nicely round out the meal. The praise from the boss should have been enough to keep me satisfied for the evening, but I couldn't get over the guilt I was feeling. I've been feeling terrible for ordering the sea bass.
In the process of planning the menu, I received an email
from the boss' wife stating that she is currently on a Chilean sea bass kick. I probably could have ignored that tidbit without anyone noticing, but I am in the business of doing what it takes to please. I ordered the sea bass.
The email sent to my provisioner specified Marine Stewardship Council-certified Chilean sea bass. She told me was the only kind she supplied. This made me feel a bit better, but even so, I had my doubts. Since the 1990s, the huge demand on Chilean sea bass has caused the population to decline to dangerous levels. Worse, it is caught by long-line fishing, which can decimate other fish species as well. Add in the issue of illegal fishing due to the high demand and you have an ecological nightmare.
There is, however, one fishery that has obtained the MSC certification, the South Georgia Island fishery. It's a co-op of sorts. While I respect the authority and opinion of the Marine Stewardship Council, a part of me wonders about the certification process of the individual fish. Even though I was told the fish I purchased did indeed have this certification, could I really be sure? Apparently, some mislabeled fish even turn up at high-end supermarkets. How could I know that my Chilean sea bass was not mislabeled as well? I didn't, but I bought it anyway.
I do have a certain amount of leeway in terms of the dishes I choose to prepare. I do my best to appease the boss and his guests, but there are some items I would downright refuse to cook on moral grounds: veal, foie gras, blue fin tuna. Besides, I highly doubt they would even ask. Other dishes are a bit trickier, as much as I have a great rapport with the owner; it is not appropriate to push my ethical beliefs on him or his guests. I do my best to provision the boat with ethically conscious, sustainable foods. Furthermore, I have no budget holding me back. This allows me to buy pasture-raised dairy products, grass-fed beef, free-range poultry. I try my best to abide by my values. Unfortunately, in this position, I'm not paid to teach ethics. No one wants to be chastised or criticized for what they choose to put in their mouths, and it's not my place to do that. I'll save that for my next career path.