Does Scott Conant Make the World's Best Tomato Sauce?

conant.jpg
TV toque Scott Conant (Chopped, 24 Hour Restaurant Battle) has been hailed as the god of tomato sauce for the (deceptively) simple "spaghetti tomato & basil" he serves at his Scarpetta restaurants in New York, Miami Beach, Las Vegas, and Beverly Hills. 

Pretty much everyone who's tasted it says it is to your typical spaghetti with tomato sauce what a Lamborghini Murcielago is to an old pair of flip-flops, which is pretty much to say it's the best goddamned tomato sauce on the planet. 

Which got Charlie wondering... One, is any spaghetti with tomato sauce, no matter how spectacularly splendiferous, worth Scarpetta's $24 price tag? And, two, can a modestly talented home cook replicate this Italianate elixir in his own kitchen? 

conant2 (640x480).jpg
The first question you'll have to answer for yourself. As to the second question, the answer is yes. And the result is a seriously delicious and quite possibly planet-worthy tomato sauce.  For a tutorial on how to make Scott Conant's best tomato sauce in the world, go here

For a few tips I picked up in the making, read on. 

• If you can't get really ripe, flavorful tomatoes (which in South Florida is pretty much a given) and you don't have any San Marzanos to bulk up the flavor of our pathetic, tomato-like specimens, try the Mario Batali trick of caramelizing a tablespoon or so of tomato paste in olive oil before adding the fresh tomatoes. A pinch of sugar wouldn't hurt either.

• Even if the sauce isn't too thick, strain the tomato "likker" and seeds and add the result to the sauce. Our tomatoes need all the help they can get.

• Add more than a pinch of salt at the beginning to cook its flavor into the tomatoes, but the chili flakes are better added to the finishing oil, which you'll strain and drizzle into the tomato sauce just before serving.

• Make extra basil-garlic-chili oil. It will keep in the fridge for a week and is great for sautéing, using in marinades, or just brushing on toasted bread.

• Don't forget to add the pasta water. It really does help the sauce adhere to the pasta.

• If you want to add some protein to the dish, grilled scallops or shrimp or even calamari makes an excellent complement.

• Also don't forget to thank me for saving you $24.

Location Info

Scarpetta

4441 Collins Ave., Miami Beach, FL

Category: Restaurant

Like this Story?

Sign up for the Dining Newsletter: The week's top local food news and events, plus interviews with chefs and restaurant owners, dining tips, and a peek at our print review.

Privacy Policy
Sign up for free stuff, news info & more!

Tools